Searching for a nice rod has always been one of my favorite parts of preparation. Actually chosing (i.e. deciding for one) is not that easy though. There are multiple selection criteria and you never get it all in one package (unless you take the price out of the equation). My decision depends on: technical parameters, quality of the components, feeling, design, reputation, price. The technical parameters (lure weight, rod length, max drag, PE class, transport length) must be suited for the task and they are the most important criterion. But since I never fished for GT before (not even any other tropical species) I can only rely on other people's experience in this case. In order to do that I browsed internet forums (such as
Big Game Board,
GT Popping or
360 Tuna) and read through recommendations of fishing guides (such as
Andres Expeditions (German) or
Green Fishing (French)). From all those different sources I tried to collect information about the typical lure weight, the required line strength (that reflects in the PE number of a rod) and the typical rod length. Here is the result:
Manufacturer |
Model |
Lure Weight |
PE Class |
Rod Length |
Transport Length |
Rod Weight (gr) |
Max Drag at 45° (kg) |
Price |
Carpenter |
Monster Hunter 80H |
250 |
8-10 |
8.0 |
167 |
430 |
13 |
75,000 YEN |
Carpenter |
Coral Viper 79/40 |
200 |
6-8 |
7.9 |
168.5 |
385 |
12 |
75,000 YEN |
Carpenter |
The Blue Lagoon 80/40 |
240 |
8 |
8.0 |
170 |
400 |
13 |
75,000 YEN |
FCL Labo |
UCB81 Extreme |
180 |
8-10 |
8.1 |
177 |
380 |
|
800 AUS |
Fisherman |
GT-GAME-T |
220 |
8 |
7.6 |
151 |
- |
- |
101,600 YEN |
Hammerhead |
Faube 77M+ |
180 |
10 |
7.7 |
167 |
385 |
11 |
- |
HOTS |
GIPANG 79XH |
230 |
6-10 |
7.9 |
- |
- |
- |
51,975 YEN |
Patriot Design |
World Combat GTZ Black Mafia 76 |
230 |
8-12 |
7.6 |
- |
515 |
17 |
95,000 YEN |
Race Point (by Saltywater Tackle) |
Race Point 250 |
180 |
10 |
7.5 |
- |
395 |
16 |
700 USD |
Ripple Fisher |
Fanta Stick GT79 reversal |
120-180 |
10 |
7.9 |
- |
390 |
- |
887 USD, 895 EUR |
Ripple Fisher |
Final Spirit GT79H |
170-220 |
12 |
7.9 |
- |
395 |
- |
887 USD, 63,000 YEN |
Ripple Fisher |
Ultimo 79MH UG Swim |
160 |
8 |
7.9 |
- |
357 |
- |
63,000 YEN |
Shimano |
Kaibutsu Surface Monster |
250 |
- |
7.8 |
147 |
- |
- |
350 EUR |
Smith |
WRC-Komodo Dragon |
300 |
12 |
7.6 |
162 |
430 |
10 |
82,950 YEN |
Smith |
WRC-Tokara60 |
250 |
12 |
7.6 |
- |
420 |
13 |
610 EUR, 74,550 YEN |
Temple Reef |
Reefer 711-10 |
170 |
10 |
7.11 |
174 |
410 |
14 |
690 USD |
Xzoga |
Taka Pi 7708 |
450 (officially), ~150 (in practice) |
8 |
7.7 |
- |
410 |
20 |
414 USD, 419 EUR |
Zenaq |
Fokeeto 80-10 |
230 |
7-10 |
8.0 |
175 |
- |
423 |
- |
Notice / Update: in the meantime I have removed and added some rods. The ones removed were either rarely recommended in expert forums or no GT rods. I've added some rods like Racepoint or Temple Reef but for those I couldn't find a lot of reviews / feedback in the internet.
The next thing I did was analyzing all that data and deriving average numbers. Why? Well, I do not trust one single person's opinion (since there is a lot of hidden advertisement). But when you aggregate all those people's opinions than you get a quite reliable look at the essence. And here it is:
The average popping rod is 8 ft long (244cm) and it is optimized for lures weighing up to 190 grams and PE class 8 (which means 100lb braided line). It should be able to support a drag force of at least 10 kg (22lb). It consists of two parts: the handle and the main rod, where the main rod part is longer, around 175cm in average.
What I couldn't find out from reading through internet pages is the feeling of the rod. This is the biggest drawback of my research and here in Germany there aren't a lot of shops where I could touch those rods. That's too bad, since the feeling is a very subjective quality, I believe.
Speaking of design: well, interestingly, the cheaper rods look fancier (in my opinion) where the more expensive ones almost look alike, very simple. But this is understatement, guys. Apparently, it's the feeling that sets them apart. And honestly, I haven't fished for GT yet but from freshwater fishing I can confirm that this is the most important aspect. So I trust the experts here.
Speaking of reputation and price: the more expensive, the more praise. Interestingly, I noticed that there is a difference between the information that you find in global forums and country-specific forums. Apparently, some manufacturers focus their marketing on single markets (e.g. OTI (on USA), Xzoga (on Germany), Tenryu (on France)) which raises my suspection but you may think of that what you will. One thing is safe to say though: Fisherman, Carpenter, Smith and Ripple Fisher are the most praised brands, and the most expensive ones. Carpenter and Ripple Fisher introduced quite a lot of innovations over the last years, where Fisherman and Smith rely on models that were mostly introduced some 10 years ago (but still get praise).
Now, let's talk money finally: all these rods aren't cheap exactly. (Notice: the prices that you find in the table above are subject to changes.) Usually, I start with a medium-prized rod. Only here, there is none. Another approach is to look at availability. Many Japanese rods aren't available outside of Japan or their price is considerably higher in US or EU internet shops. I compared Japanese prices to US or EU prices using X-Rates and I identified only one EU shop that resells Japanese rods at a reasonable price. I'd advice you to do the same before chosing a rod. The best thing you can do for sure is to buy rods in Japan (if you happen to go there or have a friend travelling there).
There is a very useful guide (by Brandon Khoo) to buying popping rods on GTPopping.com. Read it!
Have fun deciding for yourself.
Tight lines.